In Defense of Edward Said

Salam alaikum,


Please take a look at this awful piece by the usually reasonable Gary Kamiya:


How Edward Said took intellectuals for a ride
By Gary Kamiya


http://www.salon.com/books/feature/2006/12/06/orientalism/index.html 


I wrote the following on eteraz.org in response: http://www.eteraz.org/story/2006/12/6/16639/8942.  


Mohammad 

Comments

Therein lies the

Therein lies the revolutionary contribution Said made to a field — Islamic Studies — that was not even his own: he showed how ideological commitments — in this case commitments to the superiority of Western civilization — could not only lead to profound mischaracterizations of the subject of study, but also how such errors can become core doctrines of a discipline.’ Fadel


good point to keep in mind when reading ‘expert’ opinions.

Said's books Orientalism was

Said’s books Orientalism was a tad bit dry and boring at times, as was some of his other books.


He reminds me of Rushdie in some ways, I like them when they talked, but their academic writings, spare me the bore.

Back to top