Guardian review of Ed Husain's book, "The Islamist"

The UK Guardian has a good review of the latest book attacking Muslim fundamentalism in Europe. The author, Ed Husain, was previously a member of Hizbut Tahrir, but has now become another poster boy of the right wing for providing support for all their suspicions of terrorist sympathizing amongst European Muslims. I like the way the reviewer puts it:



It is as if, just as Husain once swallowed large chunks of Hizb ut-Tahrir propaganda, he now seems to have swallowed undigested the prevailing critique of British Muslims. He has no truck with the idea of Islamophobia, which he dismisses as the squeal of an Islamist leadership pleading special favours; he criticises Asian racism and castigates Muslims "who go back home to get married" and produce "another generation confused about home". On issues such as segregation, he is confident it is the fault of multiculturalism.


Husain’s book will be used in many debates – the future of multiculturalism, whether infringements of civil liberties are necessary to combat terrorism, what parts of Islamist histories from Asia and the Middle East a British Muslim community needs to jettison. One suspects the naivety which took him into Hizb-ut Tahrir has blinded him as to how his story will be used to buttress positions hostile to many things he holds dear – his own faith and racial tolerance, for example. A glance at the blog response to a Husain piece in the Telegraph reveals how rightwing racism and anti-Islamic sentiment are feasting on his testimony.


Comments

I agree with ed that there

I agree with ed that there is far more unpleasant twaddle tolerated within the British Muslim community than is good for anyone. At the same time, his analysis is simplistic – I’m very much orientated towards to Sufi/proggie end of things, although I am vehemently opposed to both islamophobia and Orientalism as  well as passionately rejecting the anti-conservatism of some proggie Musies. Sweeping analyses are, inevitably, playing to political tunes and Hussein is doing just that. I don’t think he should be condemned – he should just be advised to check out who he now has for allies and friends and ask if he that’s the kind of people with whom he really wants to be associated.

Talking about Hussein give

Talking about Hussein give him the feeling that he is prominent; he is not.


His ideas are nothing more than an expression of freedom of speech.  lets move on!

Back to top