Recovering from False Modesy

I want to send a thank you note to the show "What Not to Wear." Actually, I did. I wrote them way back when and thanked them for teaching me that I could wear clothes that flatter my figure and my character. I am 5-10 and weigh 170ish of well-distributed womanhood. I am the product of peasant genes on both sides of my family. I look like one of those women who could pull a plow all day long, give birth to her baby in the field, tuck the newborn in her dress to suckle, and keep plowing because she can just sense that the rain is coming soon and she's got to get the seeds in….you know that kind of woman. This is not a woman who wears certain kinds of women's clothes well. After I grew out of Punk, I never knew what to wear. I was dowdy. Then when I became a Muslim, I added long and baggy to dowdy. Long skirts, long shirts, comfortable shoes. Drab. Why? Partly because I just didn't know how to dress, partly because I just didn't know what dressing modestly meant, and partly because I had no sense of myself as a woman.


The show helped me figure out what kinds of jackets to buy, fitted dress shirts, what kinds of pants, skirts, how to do something trendy without looking foolish, that sort of thing. I discovered those little fitted jackets cover well, yet give me a waist. Those jeans with the small legs and the high waists, very bad. Upside down triangle. Very bad. My body? Better to wear low waisted straight-legs. That style showed less of my real shape than the old jeans and gave me a more modest and actually more attractive look. Who knew?


They have this whole "age-appropriate" attitude on the show. How to look beautiful in an age appropriate way. Turns out age-appropriate means modest. The hosts on "What Not to Wear" kept talking about what clothes "say" about a person. Work clothes, do they "say" professional or lazy slob? Date clothes? Do they "say" I have self-respect or I am a door-mat? I had just started my job at Skidmore and I realized that I had no decent professional clothes. But I also realized that wearing flattering clothes, having a great hair-cut, and showing my beauty did not mean signaling that I was available for no-nonsense no-questions asked fun later that night. I discovered that I could learn the language of clothes.


Now at the time I was still living with my husband who was quite ill so I wasn't looking for make "my husband happy" or "date clothes." But I did start to learn, slowly, through following the dress-rules on the show that I was attractive. I started to learn I could be myself, I could be Muslim, and be attractive. When I finally left him and was living on my own, this was knowledge that came in handy. Date clothes. How do you dress such that a man knows you are somewhat available and yet maintain one's desired boundaries? Well like I was to find out about dating and learning about men and their various types after nearly 15 years with just one man, it would take practice.


I discovered that different clothes made me different people. I could put on a personality, I could put on confidence, I could put on woman, I could put on anything. Now don't you know that required a little self-examination on my part. In other words, who am I now that I am not with "the husband"? My whole Muslim life was with him. I hadn't known much self-respect in my marriage. These clothes I started wearing acted as self-respect costumes. I could wear some of them and put on some self-respect. No connection to the cut or brand. It was only that I was figuring out who I am after all these years. I was picking out and trying on clothes for the person I wanted to become. First and foremost, I wanted to be an intelligent beautiful woman who had self-respect.


So of course that meant I had to own at least one pair of black high-heeled Prada boots.

Comments

Muslim Hedonist So, not only

Muslim Hedonist


So, not only the devil wears Prada… (just kidding).


But seriously, I think that this post touches on a number of important issues. The conservative Muslim community I am associated with has very simplistic ideas of modesty: for them, modesty means wearing a head-scarf and long, loose clothing which conceals all curves in the very least.


How then can anyone coming from such a background conceptualize being “modest” without a scarf? I would say that the modesty discourse in my community is set up in this way in order to discourage women from exploring the idea that there are different ways of being modest.


I suppose this is why when some women from the Muslim world come here and cease wearing scarves, that they go to the other extreme of wearing extremely revealing clothing. The existence of a middle ground is not acknowledged.


The issue of clothing and self-confidence is another thing which my community doesn’t address. Women who find that wearing hijab in a professional context makes them less confident are made to feel that this is simply a sign of their weak faith, and they need to attend more halaqas or something. Or, they are told that Ingrid Mattson has no problem teaching at Harvard in a hijab, so what are they worried about.


Reinventing oneself after years and years of buying in to such discourses is definitely challenging. Laury, you’re an inspiration.

I think something similar

I think something similar happened to me in college. I wound up only wearing black. =)

I really liked this. One of

I really liked this. One of the things I most readily believe about fashion is that there are many ways of reaching one goal. My friends who convert to Islam and suddenly sport black abayas, then complain about getting sun-burned through the material and not being able to breathe… I just tell them, look, you don’t HAVE to look like you’ve just landed in Riyadh. You can find your own look and comfort-zone.


Of course, it doesn’t help when members of their community throw rocks at them for not dressing EXACTLY like a very conservative Arab might… Is this all about the whole “Arab is better” thing again?

I heard that TJ Winter gave

I heard that TJ Winter gave a talk awhile back at a Zaytuna Rihla that women didn’t need to do this ugly black coat look. He emphasized that there are distinct and beautiful Islamic styles from all over the world. I am not sure if he mentioned the distinct and beautiful American Muslim styles, like Nakia’s jeans and a dress over it (with totally freaky shoes, I hope). But the overall point was appreciated.


We need a color and good fabric jihad in women’s clothes!

The Fashion Jihad must

The Fashion Jihad must include :
establishing natural fibers in the closets of the believers,
enjoining righteous colors and forbidding evil shades, such as baby puke green,
training designers and tailors to make use of traditional and contemporary weapons against sack-like shapeless garments, for the beautification of the ummah,
and last, and actually most important, making sure that all who participate in the beautification of the ummah are well paid and treated in their work, in accordance with Islaam.
Our slogan: Allah is beautiful. Get the hint.

I commit myself!

I commit myself!

Back to top